"You've got a torn ACL"
Dr. John Hoffman


I originally injured my ACL about 5 years before I had ACL surgery. I was playing touch football with a bunch of guys and I was running full speed. The ball carrier cut back the other way, so I started to cut back to catch him. When I did, my foot caught in the grass and my momentum kept me going in the original direction... I kind of hyper-extended it a little and then heard the infamous "pop". I felt pain immediately and went right to the ground. It took the breath right out of me. It also seemed to start swelling right away. I got up and hobbled home (I only lived a block away.) I used ice and elevated it, but it got pretty swollen and sore. I don't remember for sure how long it was before I could walk on it. A couple of days anyway. Eventually, the swelling went down and it started to feel better. I never did see the doctor.

About 10 days later, I went to play another game of football... this one had been planned for a month or so and I didn't want to miss it. I wrapped my knee up and went on my way. Everything went well until about halfway through the game. I had just caught a ball and was on my way to picking up a good 20 yards when a guy came in low and hit me from the side right on the knee. I could feel it go out of place and heard a faint "pop". That was it for the day. I could still walk on it and I got to my car and went home. I took care of this one the same way... with ice and elevation. I could walk on it the next day so I wasn't really concerned.

A couple months passed and I didn't have any more problems. I was still playing football and basketball, I was just careful of which foot to plant. One afternoon while I was playing 2 on 2 basketball, I went up for a rebound and came down on someone elses foot. I felt my knee go out of place and then it went right back in. I hate that feeling!! I was in a lot of pain, so one of the guys took me in to the emergency room at the hospital. They were little to no help. The told me to stay off of it for a while and wrap it up. They didn't say anything about ice or if had a torn ACL or anything. It was a total waste of money. They took x-rays and that was it.

I made an appointment to see a doctor the following week. When I saw him, he said I probably had a torn ACL, because my knee was a little loose. He said I could try to rehab it and try to avoid surgery, so that's what I did. BIG mistake.

I rehabbed and continued to play sports. I probably averaged about 2 injuries/year. They weren't always severe, but they involved my knee "giving away." The last injury happened on November 8th, 1998. I was playing touch football and I had the ball, I turned to do a flea-flicker and my knee gave way. Again, there was a faint "pop." I sat out for a while, I could put some weight on it, so I played for the last half as quarterback. That way I wouldn't have to run... I could just chuck the ball away if I was going to get sacked. After it was over, I went home and took care of it. At that point, I decided I had had enough.

I saw a new doctor the following week... I already knew I had a torn ACL and was ready for surgery. So I went in, he checked me out and asked me what I wanted to do. I said "fix it." He said ok and explained how he would perform the surgery. I made an appointment to have the surgery in two weeks.

On December 2, 1998, I had ACL surgery using the patellar tendon method. You can read all about it and my rehab in my diary on the web.

There were a couple reasons I didn't want to have surgery in the beginning. First off, I didn't have any insurance, and I didn't have the money. There wasn't much I could do about it. The second reason was because the doctor said it would be a minimum of one year before I would be active in any kind of sports again. That's not what I wanted to hear. Of course in the process of not having the surgery, each time I reinjured my knee, I caused more damgage. I ended up with torn ACL, torn meniscus, and damage to the bone. I will have arthritis at an early age now. I do feel bad that I didn't have the surgery sooner, but I also feel lucky that methods have improved vastly in the past 5 years. Now, rehab is only 6 months and the reconstructions are more refined. Bottom line... I should have had the surgery much sooner, but it's definitely better late than never.

If you have any questions or comments, please e-mail me by clicking here.

ACL Main Page - Main Index Page

How my ACL injury happened - This is the story of how I tore my ACL.

Diary of an ACL Surgery Patient - I  kept a diary of everything I was going through before, during and after my ACL surgery.

What Types of ACL grafts are there? - Here are the 3 basic types of ACL grafts.

ACL Blog - You can find the newest info here.

ACL FAQ (Frequently Asked Questions) - Here is everything you wanted to know about ACL injury/recovery/surgery, but were afraid to ask. Ok, maybe not everything, but this list continues to grow as I receive new questions.

Related Links - Here are some links to other sites